
CÍMLAP
Karády Viktor
Ethnic and denominational inequalities and conflicts in elites and elite training in modern Central-Europe
CONTENTS, TABLE DES MATIÈRES, PREFACE
Contents, Table des matiėres
Preface
Universities and Nation States
The heritage of medieval universities
The German and the French pattern of national universities
The making of national universities
Bibliography
The Overall Survey of Educated Elites in Pre-Socialist Hungary - 1867-1948. (Issues, Approaches, Sources)
Historical stages and sociological scope
The research project on the elites
Topical approaches and problem areas in the overall prosopographical survey
Juifs et Allemands dans les publics universitaires en Hongrie à l'époque de la Double Monarchie
Problèmes de méthode
Les principaux groupes ethniques dans le corps estudiantin
Anti-Semitism. An Interpretation
The Christian heritage
Secularisation of the Christian heritage
The logic and the references of secular anti-Semitism
Conclusion
Education and the modern Jewish experience in Central Europe
Education and Denominations in Transdanubia around 1910
Les Conditions socio-géographiques des pérégrinations universitaires Est-Ouest a l'époque moderne
Le recrutement des étudiants de Hongrie à l'étranger pendant la grande transformation (1867-1918). (Perspectives comparatistes.)
L'évolution du poids des études à l'étranger
La sélection par l'ethnicité et par le culte
Le recrutement socio-professionnel
Les Juifs de l'Est européen et la demande d'études supérieures en France avant et après la Grande Guerre
La refonte républicaine du dispositif universitaire postnapoléonien
Les Juifs et les facteurs de "poussée" dans la demande d'études des étrangers en France
Les étudiants étrangers et l'afflux des Juifs
Oscillations et retournement de tendance dans l'entre-deux - guerres
Bibliographie
Transylvanian Students Abroad in the late Dual Monarchy. (A Case Study of Confessional Inequalities in Elite Training)
Preliminary remarks
Confessional disparities in the intellectual professions
Peregrination strategies
The options for study tracks abroad
Conclusion
The Failed Educational Conversion of the Hungarian
Nobility (as Exemplified by Studies Abroad)
Some Characteristics of the Hungarian Nobility
Reasons of the survival of a feudal elite in modern times
The social uses of student peregrinations in Dualist Hungary
The nobility among students abroad
Conclusion
Investissements scolaires de la noblesse en Hongrie pendant le long 19e siècle
Preface
The studies of this volume are concerned with long term processes of
educational investments of various social clusters marked by their ethnic,
denominational or social status. The focus is on Hungary as well as the
rest of the Habsburg Monarchy, but not exclusively. The time span is
related to the long period of relatively peaceful modernization following
the 1867 Austro-Hungarian Compromise, the emancipation of Jews and the
industrial Gründerzeit of Central European societies in an imperial
framework. This did not exclude, indeed it permitted and sometimes even
supported - like precisely in the educational field - movements of
nationalization or nation building.
Hungary constitutes of course a borderline historical case of nation
building, since its titular elites represented a dominant ethnic minority
only, while enjoying full sovereignty in all matters internal and sharing
as equal partners the burden and the benefits of the 'common affairs'
(money, defense and diplomacy) with the other parts of the Austrian Empire.
The explicit Hungarian focus of these studies carry thus decisive thematic
implications. Their main target has to do with denominational, ethnic and
social inequalities of education in the only European society under
modernization which was equally lacking ethnic and denominational
majorities, while it continued to be ruled largely up to end by descendents
of the historic gentry of Magyar ethnic stock or national commitment. This
meant, obviously enough, that the ethnic and social dimensions of
educational demand must be in the center of investigations destined to
elucidate the question of schooling inequalities.
This explains why several of the essays here are dedicated to problems
related to the involvement of ethnic and social clusters in schooling,
especially in its most advanced echelons, universities. Three of the latter
deal with the presence of Jews and two other with that of noblemen in
higher education. But one could hardly enter into such rather singular
problem areas without a close look at the institutional development of
modern European educational systems, accomplished everywhere in the
continent according to the two dominant patterns, the Humboldtian
(Prussian) Forschungsuniversität and the post-Napoleonic Université. This
was the task undertaken in the introductory study to the volume. But
similarly I had to propose some basic methodological statements as well
about the way the historical study of educational systems in a national
society like Hungary can be approached thanks to the technical tools now at
our disposal in our computerized post-modern era. This is done in the
second study of the volume. It is followed by a statistical analysis of
fundamental data gathered from our collective survey of Hungarian students
engaged in higher education under the Dual Monarchy, particularly as
regards the two best educated cultural-ethnic clusters of the time - Jews
and Germans. But one cannot dispense with the analysis of anti-Semitism in
Central Europe when bringing Jews in the focus, all the more because one of
the explicit topics of contemporary Jew-hatred originated in and was
constantly resourced by references to 'excessive Jewish education' and
the alleged 'invasion by Jews' of the intellectual professions. Such
developments were in reality part of the fundamental process of ethnically
distinctive unequal modernization, opposing Jews to Gentiles in general,
but also Germans to most other ethnic clusters in the non Germanic
territories of East Central Europe. But the reference to Jews, historically
a most mobile group, marked by both constrained and strategic mobility
patterns, raises the issue of migration trends in modern Hungary with
particular focus on minorities. This is discussed in a special paper
pointing, there again, to significant ethnic and denominational
differentials.
These rather general - though empirically documented - essays were meant to
introduce the rest of the studies in the volume. They are indeed devoted to
more specific issues, which correspond nevertheless to rather well known
orientations of contemporary research in the social history of elites. From
the various themes approached here two emerge as particularly important,
while they are somewhat neglected by historians in this part of the world.
One has to do with the territorial foci of educational inequalities in
Hungary (Transdanubia) and in the Cisleithenian part of the Habsburg
Monarchy - the latter implying regional comparisons of educational
investment of Jews and non Jews in various Austrian provinces. The other
topical area dealt with here in not less than five studies concerns student
peregrinations abroad in the modern age. A vast array of particular
subjects are broached here via statistical indicators. Two of them have
been already evoked above about the highly conservative and on the whole
limited educational investments of the Hungarian nobility abroad during the
long 19th century. Two other essays examine the extent and the nature
(by study choices and options for countries and individual institutions)
of Hungarian migrant students in universities outside the frontiers,
especially in Vienna and Germany. For this demonstration a remarkably
precise set of prosopographical data banks is now available thanks to
meticulous research efforts by Hungarian scholars. Finally, a West European
case of the policies vis-à-vis foreign students - that of France under
the Third Republic - is exposed to a systematic scrutiny. Here again we
can identify the special questions raised by the strong - sometimes
overwhelming - Eastern Jewish presence among the migrant clientele of
higher educational institutions of the very country which consented to host
the largest contingent of visiting students from abroad before the Second
World War.