"Artificial towns" in the 21st century
Social Polarisation in the New Town Regions of East-Central Europe
CONTENTS, RECOMMENDATIONContents
Recommendation (Pierre Merlin)
Preface (Viktória Szirmai)
PART I. THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
European New Towns in the 21st Century: An Introduction (Viktória Szirmai)
The issues
Relevancy of the new towns' development model
"Socialist" New Towns' Development: the Formation Period (Viktória Szirmai)
Determining urbanistic doctrines
Principal objectives of new towns' development
The Main Characteristics of East-Central European Urbanisation Processes (Viktória Szirmai)
A different or a delayed model?
The impacts of transition
Social-spatial polarisation
Social-Spatial Mechanisms and Urban Changes in Hungary (Viktória Szirmai)
Under-urbanisation issues
The historical background of urban and rural inequalities
Deepening urban and rural inequalities
The social structure of the Hungarian metropolitan areas
Urban Development in Poland, from the Socialist City to the Post-Socialist and Neoliberal City (Grzegorz Węcławowicz)
The historical background to urbanisation
Urbanisation under centrally planned economy
Polish cities as socialist cities
The transformation of Polish cities into post-socialist cities
Toward the neoliberal city?
The main component of urban policy in Poland
Conclusions
Developmental Changes in Slovakia's Socio-Spatial Situation (Peter Gajdoš)
Introduction
Historical development of Slovakia's socio-spatial situation
Development of the socio-spatial situation in Slovakia during the period of transformation
Specific features of transformation changes in towns and their socio-spatial structure
Settlement and regional impacts of the socio-economic differentiation of society
Conclusions
PART II. SOCIAL-SPATIAL POLARISATION MECHANISMS IN THE EAST-CENTRAL EUROPEAN NEW TOWN REGIONS - THE CASE STUDIES
Social Polarisation in Tatabánya and its Region (Júlia Schuchmann)
Introduction
The specificities of the transition period
The main trends of socio-spatial polarisation
Conclusions
Social and Economic Transition in Dunaújváros and its Region (Nóra Baranyai)
Introduction
The social characteristics
Features of the social polarisation
The future of the local society
Conclusions
Social and Economic Transformation in Komló and its Region (Levente Halász)
Introduction
The town's historical development
The decline
Social and demographic characteristics
Urban economy
Social polarisation
Spatial polarisation
Conclusions
Economic Restructuring and Social Polarisation in Kazincbarcika and its Region (Márton Berki)
Introduction
History of the new town
Demographic, educational and housing characteristics
Economy and business environment
Social polarisation
Polarisation processes of the new town region
Conclusions
The Former "New Socialist City" in the Neoliberal Condition - The Case of Tychy in Poland (Grzegorz Węcławowicz - Dagmara Mliczyńska-Hajda)
Introduction
New town concepts versus the concept of the socialist city
The industrial city as the model for the socialist city
The perception of the post-1989 problems and crises
Conclusions
Nová Dubnica and its Region: The Slovak Case Study Peter Gajdoš - Katarína Moravanská)
Introduction
The geographical location and history of Nová Dubnica and its region
Characteristics of the growth of the Nová Dubnica region and current processes of its formation
The socio-demographic structures and socio-spatial polarisation
Conclusions
PART III. POSITIONS OF NEW TOWN REGIONS IN THE URBAN NETWORK - SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES
Social Polarisation Mechanisms in the Hungarian New Town Regions (Adrienne Csizmady - Zoltán Ferencz)
Introduction
New town societies versus the societies of large urban regions
Characteristics of the spatial-social structure
Comparison of the spatial-social structures
Conclusions
Post-Socialist New Towns in the Urban Network (János Rechnitzer - Judit Berkes - Ádám Páthy)
Introduction
The rankings of post-socialist towns
The internal divisions of the post-socialist new towns
Conclusions
The Hungarian Old and New Towns - The Results of the Comparative Analyses (Adrienne Csizmady)
Specificities of the historical background
Impacts of socialist development policy (1945-1989)
The features of the transition period (1990-2014)
Conclusions
Urban Structures and Architectural Specificities in the Post-Socialist New Towns (Kornélia Kissfazekas)
Introduction
General aspects of planning
Urban structure - urban-scale formal and structural characteristics
City centres
Changes in urban architecture and image
Dunaújváros
Kazincbarcika
Mining towns - Tatabánya and Komló
The Polish example - Tychy
The Slovakian example - Nová Dubnica
Conclusions
PART IV. CONCLUSIONS
The Main Social Polarisation Features of the East-Central European New Town Regions (Viktória Szirmai)
Introduction
Path dependency and the contemporary changes
Social polarisation among the post-socialist new towns
A "new" urban development model or merely an unfulfilled promise?
Conclusions
References
APPENDIX
List of Authors
List of Figures
List of Tables
List of Maps
Subject Index
Photos
Recommendation
New towns were constructed in many parts of the world and in various periods since antiquity, including a lot of medieval cities, despite the fact that the Middle Ages was not a period of rapid urban growth in Europe. But what is considered as the "New Town Movement" took place during the 20th century after the publication of the famous book by Ebenezer Howard ("Tomorrow: a peaceful path to real reform", 1898, reprinted under the title "Garden Cities of Tomorrow) and translated into many languages. The first "garden cities" were built in the London area (Letchworth from 1903, Welwyn after 1919) and later on in France, in the United States and in many other countries (New Delhi, etc.).
But, between the two World Wars, the original New Town Movement faced a rival movement, developed by "modern" architects who organised the "Congre`s internationaux d'architecture moderne (CIAM)" and adopted the "Charte d'Athènes" (1933). After World War II, most architects and urban planners adhered to the CIAM principles and most reconstruction works as well as new urbanisation in Europe were attempts, although not always successful, to respect the rigid rules of the Charte d'Athènes. Only in Britain, the post-war new towns were in the line of Howard's theory and of the first garden cities. In the Netherlands, Sweden, Finland and elsewhere, new towns were planned according to the CIAM. As early as the 1930s, and after the war, more than one thousand "socialist towns" were built in the Soviet Union as applications of the Charte d'Athènes revised by the "constructivist" Russian architects. French new towns, whose construction was decided at the end of the 1960s, appeared as a compromise between Howard's and Le Corbusier's (the most famous of the CIAM group) ideas. In Central and Eastern Europe, the construction of new towns was decided, mostly in Poland and in Hungary, and built according to the "socialist town" model.
In most developed countries, from the 1980s, two questions appeared: ‘Should we build a new generation of new towns? What should be done with nearly completed postwar new towns?' The answer has generally been that, due to the decline of demographic growth, and also under the dominant influence of "liberal" ideology, it was useless to build other new towns in the developed countries. And for existing new towns, the best for them would be to become old towns.
In Russia and in other former socialist countries, including Central Europe, an additional question was: ‘Can the socialist new towns, developed under strict state governance and planned economy, adapt to the new context of market economy and to self- governance? For these towns what have been the consequences of the regime change, of the demographic stagnation (if not a decline) and of the loss of economic priority having been given to mining and heavy manufacturing activities (which was the economic base of these postwar towns)?
The interest of the book edited by Viktoria Szirmai is precisely to scrutinise how the socialist towns of Central Europe coped with this brutal change of the political, economic and social context in the 1990s and 2000s. Through several studies written by the specialists of urban development from these countries, the book is concerned mostly with Hungarian new towns (chapters are devoted to Dunaújváros, Komló, Kazinbarcika and Tatabánya) but also with Polish (Tychy) and even Slovak ones (the small town of Nová Dubnica). It appears that these towns were handicapped by their narrow economic specialisations and by a population which was lacking middle- and upper-class families. But most of them succeeded in their adaptation to self- governance. The demographic and social evolution is more controversial. Some towns still have an unbalanced demographic structure, while other ones benefit from a better equilibrium due to ageing and the partial replacement of the original population. The economic level has generally increased, but the educated young population has difficulties to find jobs in towns still dominated by manufacturing activities and this induces significant out-migration.
The book is not limited to the history and the description of the present state of these new towns, not even to a presentation of the evolution since the drastic change of 1989. It includes a lot of comparisons, mostly based on the Hungarian situation: with large metropolitan areas, with other medium-sized cities, etc., in order to point out similarities and differences. The book is mostly written by specialists of social sciences and will concern mainly social planners.
What is the future of these socialist towns? For the main author, there are more questions than answers about their possible evolutions: "What will the new towns do with their heritage? Are they able to build on the peculiarities they exclusively possess? Are they able to build on their past, on their special architectural endowments, on the activities of the inhabitants who are committed to their town? Are they able to actually accommodate the economic and social requirements of today and are they able to act for the benefit of transition? Are they able to renew? Do they have the ability to establish smaller and broader regional cooperation frameworks where cooperation, the joint exploitation of benefits and not the individual competition, and not the other party's displacement is the goal?". It would have been hazardous for the book to provide a clear prognosis. Factors at work are too numerous and mostly unpredictable to allow any forecast. But the analysis included in the book may help to decide what to do in order to help the socialist towns of Central Europe to turn into successful ‘old towns'.
Pierre MERLIN
Professor at l'université de Paris-I (Panthéon-Sorbonne)
President of the Institut d'urbanisme et d'aménagement de la Sorbonne
(Town and Regional Planning Institute of the University Paris-Sorbonne)